Table 1. Brief comparison of current clinical guidelines from the Enhanced Recovery after Surgery Society and the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgery-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons

Stage ERAS Society guidelines [5] ASCRS guidelines [4]
Preadmission
 Preadmission orders Standardized order sets should be utilized
 Information, education, and counseling Patients should receive dedicated preoperative counseling routinely A preoperative discussion regarding clinical milestones and discharge criteria should be performed. Stoma teaching and counseling regarding how to avoid dehydration should be provided for patients undergoing ileostomy.
 Preoperative optimization Medical risk assessment Smoking cessation at least 4 weeks prior to surgery
 Nutrition Preoperative nutritional assessment should be offered. Patients at risk of malnutrition are recommended to have oral nutritional supplementation for 7−10 days. Oral nutritional supplementation is recommended in malnourished patients (targeting a protein intake of 1.2−1.5 g/kg/day for 1−2 weeks).
 Prehabilitation May reduce complications. Patients who are less fit may be more likely to benefit. May be considered for patients with multiple comorbidities or significant deconditioning.
 Anemia management If possible, anemia should be corrected with intravenous iron preoperatively prior to surgery, and blood transfusion should be avoided.
Preoperative
 Prevention of PONV A multimodal approach to PONV prophylaxis should be considered. Similar (recommendations for PONV, pain, SSI prevention, and fluid management are stated in the Perioperative Interventions section).
 Pre-anesthetic medication Sedative medication should be avoided if possible before surgery. A multimodal, opioid-sparing, pain management plan should be implemented before the induction of anesthesia.
Opioid-sparing multimodal re-anesthetic medication can be used.
 Antimicrobial prophylaxis Intravenous antibiotic prophylaxis should be given within 60 min before incision as a single-dose administration.
In patients receiving oral mechanical bowel preparation, oral antibiotics should be given.
 Skin preparation Chlorhexidine-alcohol-based preparation A bundle of measures (preoperative: chlorhexidine shower, bowel preparation, antimicrobial prophylaxis, chlorhexidine/alcohol skin preparation; operative: wound protector, gown and glove changes before fascial closure, antimicrobial sutures, maintaining euglycemia and normothermia) should be in place to reduce SSI perioperatively
 Bowel preparation MBP alone with IV antibiotic prophylaxis may be used for rectal surgery. MBP combined with preoperative oral antibiotics is typically recommended.
 Preoperative fasting and carbohydrate loading The patient should be allowed to eat up until 6 h and take clear fluids up until 2 h before anesthetic induction. Clear liquids may be continued up to 2 h before surgery.
Patients with delayed gastric emptying and emergency patients should fast overnight or 6 h before surgery.
Intraoperative
 Standard anesthetic protocol Avoidance of benzodiazepines Similar recommendation
Use of short-acting anesthetics
Cerebral function monitoring
Monitoring of the level and complete reversal of neuromuscular block
 Fluid and electrolyte management Maintain fluid homeostasis Even a short duration of MAP<65 mmHg should be avoided (associated with adverse outcomes, in particular myocardial injury and acute kidney injury).
GDFT should be adopted, especially in high-risk patients Similar recommendation
 Prevention of intraoperative hypothermia Reliable temperature monitoring should be undertaken.
 Surgical access Minimally invasive surgery is recommended. Similar recommendation
 Drain Pelvic and peritoneal drains should not be used routinely. Similar recommendation
 Postoperative
 Nasogastric tube Should not be used routinely Similar recommendation
If inserted during surgery, it should be removed before reversal of anesthesia.
Postoperative
 Pain control Avoid opioids and apply multimodal analgesia. Similar recommendation
TEA is recommended in open colorectal surgery. TEA is an option for open colorectal surgery (if dedicated pain team is available)
 Abdominal wall blocks TAP blocks can reduce opioid consumption and improve recovery. Laparoscopic-guided TAP block is safe and effective, and seems to be as effective as US-guided TAP block.
 Thromboprophylaxis Mechanical prophylaxis by compression stockings and/or intermittent pneumatic compression until discharge
Pharmacological prophylaxis with LMWH for 28 days after surgery
 Fluid and electrolyte management Net "near-zero" fluid and electrolyte balance should be maintained. Similar recommendation
Balanced solutions are preferred. Similar recommendation
Intravenous fluids should be routinely discontinued in the early postoperative period in the absence of surgical complications or hemodynamic instability
 Foley catheter Recommended for 1−3 days Removed within 24 h for colon−upper rectal resection Removed within 24−48 h for mid/lower rectal resection
 Nutritional care Early resumption of oral intake with oral supplementation from the day of surgery. Patient should be offered a regular diet with 24 h.
Perioperative immunonutrition for malnutrition. The efficacy of immunonutrition over standard high-protein oral nutritional supplements remains controversial.
 Early mobilization Through patient education and encouragement Early and progressive patient mobilization are associated with a shorter length of stay.
 Discharge criteria Hospital discharge prior to return of bowel function may be offered for selected patients.
Audit Collection of key outcome and process data used for repeated audits and feedback is essential
ERAS, Enhanced Recovery after Surgery; ASCRS, American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons; PONV, postoperative nausea and vomiting; SSI, surgical site infection; MBP, mechanical bowel preparation; MAP, mean arterial pressure; GDFT, goal-directed fluid therapy; TEA, transthoracic epidural analgesia; TAP, transversus abdominis plane; US, ultrasonography.