Review

Exposure to air pollution and precocious puberty: a systematic review

Rosie Lee1https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3285-3916, Jongmin Oh2,3,4https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2980-6943, Eunji Mun1https://orcid.org/0009-0008-8590-1057, Jung Eun Choi1https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8956-4192, Kyung Hee Kim1https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3795-4671, Ji Hyen Lee1,3https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2234-1055, Hae Soon Kim1,3,*https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6976-6878, Eunhee Ha2,3,5,*https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4224-3858
Author Information & Copyright
1Department of Pediatrics, Ewha Womans University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
2Department of Environmental Medicine, Ewha Womans University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
3Institute of Ewha-SCL for Environmental Health (IESEH), Ewha Womans University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
4Department of Human Systems Medicine, College of Medicine, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea
5System Health & Engineering Major in Graduate School (BK21 Plus Program), Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea
*Corresponding author: Hae Soon Kim, Department of Pediatrics, Ewha Womans University College of Medicine, 260, Gonghang-daero, Gangseo-gu, Seoul, 07804, Korea, E-mail: hyesk@ewha.ac.kr
*Corresponding author: Eunhee Ha, Department of Environmental Medicine, Ewha Womans University College of Medicine, 25, Magokdong-ro 2-gil, Gangseo-gu, Seoul 07804, Korea, E-mail: eunheeha@ewha.ac.kr

© Copyright 2024 Ewha Womans University College of Medicine and Ewha Medical Research Institute. This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: Feb 28, 2024; Revised: Apr 21, 2024; Accepted: Apr 22, 2024

Published Online: Apr 30, 2024

Abstract

The worldwide incidence of precocious puberty, which is associated with negative health outcomes, is increasing. Several studies have suggested that environmental factors contribute to the development of precocious puberty alongside genetic factors. Some epidemiological studies have provided limited evidence suggesting an association between exposure to air pollution and changes in pubertal development. This systematic review aimed to summarize existing evidence on the association between air pollution exposure and precocious puberty. Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, we searched two databases (PubMed and Web of Science) until August 2023. The included studies assessed the association between air pollutant exposure and the risk of precocious puberty, early menarche, or pubertal development. Two authors independently performed study selection and data extraction. A meta-analysis and analysis of the risk of bias were infeasible due to the limited number of studies and the heterogeneity among them. The literature search resulted in 184 studies, from which we included six studies with sample sizes ranging from 437 to 4,074 participants. The studies reported heterogeneous outcomes. Four studies found that increased exposure to air pollution was related to earlier pubertal onset. One study was inconclusive, and another suggested that air pollutant exposure may delay the onset of thelarche. Most studies suggest that exposure to air pollutants accelerates pubertal development; however, the results from the available studies are inconsistent. More extensive and well-designed longitudinal studies are required for a comprehensive understanding of the association between air pollution and precocious puberty.

Keywords: Air pollution; Endocrine disruptors; Menarche; Particulate matter; Puberty, precocious

Introduction

Background

The increasing incidence of precocious puberty is emerging as a significant medical and social issue worldwide [1,2]. A meta-analysis from 2020 reported a trend of breast development beginning approximately 0.24 years earlier every decade from 1977 to 2023 [3]. Additionally, there has been a notable decrease in the age of menarche from the 19th to the 20th century [4]. The onset of puberty is determined by both genetic and environmental factors [5,6]. Recent studies have highlighted that non-genetic lifestyle factors, such as adiposity, exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs), and air pollution, might influence the timing of pubertal onset [7]. Furthermore, several epidemiological studies have found that exposure to ambient air pollution is linked to an earlier onset of menarche in girls [8,9].

Ambient air pollution consists of a mixture of particulate matter (PM) and gaseous pollutants that originate from both human activities and natural sources. This pollution primarily includes sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), carbon monoxide (CO), and ozone (O3). PM contains various components such as heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and EDCs, all of which can interfere with the endocrine system [10,11]. When inhaled, ambient air pollution can enter the human bloodstream and be transported to various organs [12], leading to a range of health outcomes, including endocrine disruption [10]. PM can interact with estrogen receptors, triggering the release of kisspeptin, which in turn stimulates the secretion of gonadotropin-releasing hormone, thereby initiating the onset of puberty [13]. Moreover, fine particulate matter (PM2.5), with a diameter of less than 2.5 μm, as opposed to particulate matter (PM10), which has a diameter of less than 10 μm, can penetrate deeper into the body upon inhalation, potentially causing more severe adverse effects.

Currently, epidemiological studies that investigate the association between exposure to air pollution and pubertal development are limited, and their findings are inconsistent. It is important to note that, to date, no systematic review has been conducted on the relationship between exposure to air pollution and pubertal development.

Objectives

This systematic review investigated the impact of exposure to ambient air pollution on pubertal development and the risk of precocious puberty.

Methods

Ethics statement

Since this research did not involve any direct human participants or human-derived materials, it did not require approval from an institutional review board or the obtainment of informed consent.

Study design

We conducted a systematic review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) 2020 guidelines (Fig. 1). The study protocol was registered with PROSPERO on September 19, 2023 (CRD42023465050). Revisions to the protocol were necessary as assessing the risk of bias and conducting a meta-analysis proved infeasible due to the heterogeneity among the included studies.

emj-47-2-20-g1
Fig. 1. Flow diagram summarizing the process of literature search and selection. WoS, Web of Science.
Download Original Figure
Eligibility criteria

To investigate our systematic review, we defined the population, exposures, comparison, outcomes, and study designs (PECOS) parameters. The details of PECOS are as follows: a) population: infants, children, adolescents, or pediatric patients; b) exposure: air pollutants, such as PM2.5, PM10, SO2, NO, NO2, or O3; c) comparison: exposure to lower or higher levels of each specific type of air pollutants in the same population or in a control population; with provision of a measure of risk (e.g., relative risk [RR], OR, hazard ratio [HR], or mean difference [MD]); d) outcome: precocious puberty risk, early menarche risk, or pubertal development stage; and e) study design: human epidemiological studies, including prospective and retrospective cohort studies, case-control, and cross-sectional studies. We excluded abstracts, case reports, editorials, animal studies, in vivo studies, and commentaries.

Information sources

We performed a systematic search of the 1) PubMed and 2) Web of Science (WoS) databases from their inception to August 23, 2023. Only articles in English were included.

Search strategy

The search terms for the search strategy can be found in Supplement 1. Duplicate articles were eliminated using EndNote and the manual method.

Selection process

Two authors (RSL and EJM) independently reviewed the titles and abstracts and selected potentially eligible articles. Subsequently, the full texts of selected studies were examined by two authors (RSL and EJM) with the participation of other authors (JMO, KHK, JHL, HSK, and EHH) to address any disagreements and reach a consensus.

Data collection process

Two authors (RSL and JMO) extracted the following data of interest in a Microsoft Excel sheet: first author, year of publication, country, study design, follow-up period, sample size, population characteristics, exposure details, details on outcome assessment, and confounders. Furthermore, we also extracted measures of effect (i.e., RR, OR, HR, MD, and time ratio [TR]) for the association between air pollution and precocious puberty.

Data synthesis

In our initial protocol for the systematic review, we planned to conduct a meta-analysis if at least three studies shared similar study designs, analysis methods, and effect sizes. However, a meta-analysis proved infeasible due to the limited number of studies (<3) and the diverse range of study designs, including case-crossover, cohort, and cross-sectional studies. Additionally, the outcomes varied among the studies, encompassing the risk of precocious puberty, the risk of early menarche, and stages of pubertal development. Given the heterogeneity among the included studies, we created a table to outline the characteristics of the studies and the relationships between the exposures and outcomes. As a result, we were unable to perform a meta-analysis and instead provided a descriptive summary.

Results

Study selection

In our systematic search, we identified 184 studies out of the initial 212 (PubMed: 122 and WoS: 90), following the removal of duplicates. Of these, 10 full-text studies were assessed for eligibility, with 6 ultimately being included [8,9,1417]. Fig. 1 illustrates the flow diagram of the study selection process. The studies that were excluded, along with the reasons for their exclusion, are detailed in Supplement 2.

Characteristics of the included studies

Table 1 summarizes the characteristics of the six studies. Three studies were designed as cohorts [8,16,17], two were conducted as cross-sectional studies [9,15], and one was a case-crossover study [14]. These studies were conducted in China, Hong Kong, the USA, South Korea, Poland, and Germany. The sample sizes ranged from 437 to 4,074 participants, with follow-up durations spanning from 3 to 14 years. Five studies investigated exposure to ambient air pollutants such as PM2.5, PM10, SO2, NO, NO2, and O3 [8,9,1416], whereas one study analyzed traffic-related metrics [17]. Yang et al. measured air pollutant levels using inverse distance weighting; Wronka et al. assessed air quality based on data from the chief inspectorate for environmental protection; Zhao et al. utilized a land-use regression model; Jung et al. relied on air monitoring network stations; Huang et al. gathered data from a monitoring station; and McGuinn et al. used annualized traffic data from the California Department of Transportation Highway Performance Monitoring System. The outcomes of these studies varied. Two studies [8,9] focused on the risk of early menarche as their primary outcome, with the age at menarche being self-reported. One study [14] examined the incidence of precocious puberty, defined by a professional pediatrician as the activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis function and the onset of secondary sexual characteristics before the age of 8 in girls and 9 in boys. The remaining studies [1517] assessed pubertal development at a specific age using Tanner staging or measured sex hormone levels.

Table 1. Characteristics of studies assessing the association between air pollutant exposure and pubertal development
Author Country Study design Study period Sample size Age (years) Sex Female (%) Measured pollutants Outcomes
Yang et al. [14] China Case-crossover 2015–2021 2,201 7.47±1.24 96.6 PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NO2, O3 The risk of precocious puberty
Wronka et al. [8] Poland Longitudinal cohort 2015–2018* 1,257 19–25 100 PM10, PM2.5, benzene, SO2, NO The risk of early menarche
Zhao et al. [15] Germany Cross-sectional 1995–2009 1,945 10 48.4 PM10, PM2.5, NO2, O3 Pubertal development at age 10 years assessed with estradiol and testosterone
Jung et al. [9] South Korea Cross-sectional 2010–2012 639 13–17 100 PM10 The risk of early menarche
Huang et al. [16] Hong Kong Birth cohort 1997–2008 4,074 9–12 47.5 PM10, SO2, NO, NO2 Pubertal stage at age 11 years assessed with Tanner stage
McGuinn et al. [17] USA Longitudinal cohort 2005–2012 437 6–8 100 Traffic metrics Pubertal stage at 6–8 years assessed with Tanner stage

PM, particulate matter; SO2, sulfur dioxide; NO2; nitrogen dioxide; O3, ozone.

* Girls were born between 1993 and 1998.

The authors assessed children born between 1995 and 1999 when they reached the age of 10, between 2005 and 2009.

The authors assessed children born in 1997 when they reached the age of 9–12, between 2005 and 2008.

Download Excel Table
Synthesis of results
Relationship between air pollution exposure and pubertal development

Table 2 summarizes the findings on the impact of air pollution on pubertal development, precocious puberty, and age at menarche across various studies. Four out of six studies [8,9,14,17] indicated that exposure to air pollution accelerates pubertal development stages and promotes precocious puberty. Jung et al. found that a 1 μg/m3 increase in PM10 was associated with a higher risk of early menarche (OR=1.08; 95% CI, 1.04–1.12) and accelerated age at menarche by 0.046 years (95% CI, −0.064 to −0.027) on a 1-year average. The authors reported that the results were consistent across the 2-year average (OR=1.06; 95% CI, 1.02–1.10; 0.038 years; 95% CI, −0.059 to −0.018) and 3-year model average (OR=1.05; 95% CI, 1.01–1.09; 0.031 years; 95% CI, −0.047 to −0.015). Wronka et al. found that the risk of early menarche (age below 11) was higher in the group living in areas with high PM levels. The ORs were calculated as 3.18 (95% CI, 2.29–4.69) for PM10 and 3.25 (95% CI, 2.34–4.8) for PM2.5. Yang et al. used a distributed lag nonlinear model to determine the OR of the lag effect of PM2.5 and PM10 on the incidence of precocious puberty. They reported that the most significant effects of PM2.5 and PM10 on precocious puberty were observed in lag 27 (OR=1.72; 95% CI, 1.01–2.92) and lag 16 (OR=1.95; 95% CI, 1.33–2.85), respectively. McGuinn et al. found that girls living within 150 m of a major road or highway had a higher likelihood of experiencing early pubarche (TR=0.96; 95% CI, 0.93–0.99), but not thelarche (TR=0.99; 95% CI, 0.97–1.02). The authors used accelerated failure time models, and calculated TRs, where a TR of <1.0 indicated an earlier age at pubertal development than the reference group. In contrast, Huang et al. reported that exposure to PM10 during the prenatal and infantile periods could delay thelarche. Exposure to PM10, SO2, NO, and NO2 was considered as z-scores for comparability, and the outcomes were the MD in Tanner stage per SD increment in each type of air pollutant. In girls, higher PM10 exposure in utero (MD: −0.05; 95% CI, −0.08 to −0.02) and in infancy (MD: −0.03; 95% CI, −0.06 to −1.2) was associated with a lower pubertal stage. In boys, higher SO2 exposure in utero (MD: −0.03; 95% CI, −0.05, −0.01) and during childhood (MD: −0.06; 95% CI, −0.08, −0.04) were associated with lower pubertal stage. Furthermore, higher NO2 exposure in utero (MD: −0.03; 95% CI, −0.04, −0.02) and during childhood (MD: −0.02; 95% CI, −0.04, −0.01) was associated with a lower pubertal stage. Zhao et al. found no statistically significant associations between air pollution exposure and pubertal development as assessed using serum sex hormone levels.

Table 2. Relationship between air pollutant exposure and pubertal development
Author Air pollutant exposure Outcomes Effect measure Result with 95% CI Adjusted variables Average concentration of main air pollutants
Yang et al. [14] PM10 The risk of precocious puberty OR 1.95 (1.33–2.85) Age, sex, SO2, NO2, CO, O3 69.77±41.07 μg/m3
PM2.5 1.72 (1.01–2.92) 38.81±26.36 μg/m3
Wronka et al. [8] PM10 Low*
Medium
High
The risk of early menarche OR 3.18 (2.29–4.69) Urbanization, mother's education, father's education, number of siblings, financial conditions NA
PM2.5 3.25 (2.34–4.80)
Benzene 1.11 (0.90–1.64)
SO2 1.22 (1.01–2.14)
NO 1.47 (0.65–1.35)
Zhao et al. [15] PM10 10 μg/m3 increase in pollutant concentrations Pubertal development at age 10 years assessed with estradiol and testosterone OR Female: 0.896 (0.379–2.122)
Male: 0.821 (0.383–1.759)
Age, sex, body mass index, secondhand smoke exposure, time spent outside and in front of a screen, physical activity level, season, and time of the blood sampling, household income, parental education, maternal age at birth, single parent status 21.95±3.26 μg/m3
PM2.5 Female: 0.163 (0.022–1.166)
Male: 1.089 (0.156–7.605)
14.76±2.13 μg/m3
NO2 Female: 0.892 (0.581-1.369)
Male: 1.152 (0.768–1.728)
22.03±3.86 μg/m3
O3 Female: 0.900 (0.605–1.339)
Male: 0.830 (0.573–1.203)
69.18±4.9 μg/m3
Jung et al. [9] PM10 1 μg/m3 increase in PM10 The risk of early menarche OR 1.08 (1.04–1.12) Body mass index, city size, household income level, maternal age at menarche, second-hand smoke exposure at home NA
Huang et al. [16] PM10 SD increase in pollutants Pubertal stage at age 11 years assessed with Tanner stage Mean difference in Tanner stage Female
In utero: −0.05 (−0.08 to −0.02)
Infancy: −0.03 (−0.06 to −1.2)
Neighborhood and household income per person, mother's migration status, highest parental educational level, age, maternal age at birth, parity, maternal smoking NA
SO2 Male
In utero: −0.03 (−0.05 to −0.01)
Childhood: −0.06 (−0.08 to −0.04)
NO Statistically insignificant
NO2 Male
In utero: −0.03 (−0.04 to −0.02)
Childhood: −0.02 (−0.04 to −0.01)
McGuinn et al. [17] Traffic metrics Distance to road (meters) Pubertal stage at 6−8 years assessed with Tanner stage TR Pubarche: 0.96 (0.93–0.99)
Thelarche: 0.99 (0.97–1.02)
Race/ethnicity, household income, girl's cotinine level NA

PM, particulate matter; SO2, sulfur dioxide; NO2; nitrogen dioxide; CO, carbon monoxide; O3, ozone; TR, time ratio; NA, not applicable.

* Low: annual pollutant values and the number of days per year with exceedances were below the allowable limit; Medium: annual values below the permissible limit, but with the number of days exceeding the normal above the limit; High: included zones above the limit.

Statistically significant results.

Download Excel Table

Discussion

Key results

In this systematic review, we found that four out of six studies indicated a relationship between increased exposure to air pollution and earlier onset of puberty [8,9,14,17]. One study produced inconclusive results [15], while another suggested that exposure to air pollutants might delay the onset of thelarche [16].

There has been no prior systematic review examining the effects of air pollution exposure on pubertal development and precocious puberty. The studies we included employed various research designs, such as cohort, cross-sectional, and case-crossover studies, featured different sample sizes, and tracked participants over varying lengths of time. These studies also investigated different exposures and outcomes and utilized a range of methods to measure exposure. We recognize that this diversity in study design could account for the inconsistent results regarding the impact of air pollution on precocious puberty. Nevertheless, the authors are inclined to believe that air pollution adversely affects precocious puberty, based on the accumulating evidence that air pollutants influence pubertal development through various mechanisms, which are not yet fully understood.

Interpretation and comparison with previous studies

When chemicals and heavy metals with endocrine-disrupting properties are released into the air from industrial emissions, vehicle emissions, and waste combustion, they can bind to PM [18]. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and heavy metals in PM, particularly from fossil fuel combustion, are recognized as endocrine disruptors due to their ability to activate aryl hydrocarbon, androgen, or estrogen receptors [19]. PM can act on estrogen receptors, triggering the release of kisspeptin, which subsequently initiates the secretion of gonadotropin-releasing hormone, thus starting the onset of puberty [13]. Epigenetic disruption caused by PM is a potential mechanism for triggering puberty through neuroendocrine components [20]. Moreover, PM can induce oxidative stress and systemic inflammation upon entering the respiratory tract [21]. Endocrine disruptors attached to PM influence hormone synthesis in endocrine glands or disrupt hormone transport to target organs. Research using mixtures of EDCs found in indoor air samples has shown that these compounds exhibit estrogenic and androgenic activities when tested in in vitro assay systems [22]. There is increasing evidence that certain EDCs are associated with various human health issues, such as reproductive problems in both females and males, and precocious puberty in children, as indicated in several previously reported systematic reviews [2328].

Although the exact mechanisms connecting air pollutants and puberty onset remain unclear, the presence of EDCs in air, including PM, and their potential impact on puberty are areas that require active research.

Strengths and limitations of the included studies

These studies stand out for their pioneering research into the relationship between exposure to air pollutants and pubertal development. McGuinn et al. [17] conducted the first study to explore the link between early life proximity to traffic and pubertal development within a multiethnic cohort. Huang et al. utilized a population-representative birth cohort and gathered clinical data on pubertal stages. Jung et al. [9] analyzed data from the fifth Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Study, a representative sample of the South Korean population, and found consistent results across various models after making adjustments. Wronka et al. [8] carried out the inaugural study in a European country investigating the connection between air pollutant exposure and early menarche. Zhao et al. [15] also drew on data from two relatively large birth cohorts, with numerous relevant covariates available for adjustment. Yang et al. [14] employed a case-crossover study design and a distributed nonlinear model to evaluate the association between PM10 and PM2.5 levels and the risk of precocious puberty. Zhao et al. [15] and Jung et al. [9] considered body mass index as a confounding factor, acknowledging that nongenetic lifestyle factors such as adiposity can influence the onset of puberty.

Nonetheless, the included studies have several limitations. First, exposure to air pollutants was estimated using data averaged for specific geographic areas, and the limited number of air quality monitoring stations may not provide a precise representation of individual exposure. Consequently, exposure misclassification and a lack of individual-level data are possible issues. Second, some studies were susceptible to recall bias, particularly those relying on self-reported data such as age at menarche. Additionally, most studies focused on single pollutant exposure, whereas in reality, humans are exposed to a complex mixture of air pollutants [29]. Moreover, the study designs varied, encompassing different exposures to air pollutants, and the outcomes included the incidence of precocious puberty, age at menarche, and pubertal stage at a specific age. This heterogeneity in study design and outcomes made it infeasible to conduct a meta-analysis and evaluate the risk of bias.

Recommendations for future studies and health implications

Future researchers should consider conducting prospective birth cohort studies to assess the long-term consequences of prenatal and postnatal exposure to air pollution. This is crucial because EDCs can function as obesogens during pregnancy, potentially altering fetal programming [30], and air pollution may have similar effects. Furthermore, to accurately assess individual exposure to air pollution, it is feasible to use advanced technologies and methods, such as personal monitoring devices. Expanding the study population to include diverse socioeconomic groups and geographical locations can enhance the generalizability of the findings. In vitro research is also necessary to understand the biological mechanisms underlying the association between air pollution and pubertal development. Additionally, research should focus on developing prevention policies and interventions aimed at mitigating the impact of air pollution. Air pollution is a global concern, and international collaboration among researchers and institutions worldwide can lead to a more comprehensive understanding of its effects on health.

Strengths and limitations of this review

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first systematic review to provide evidence of the impact of air pollution exposure on precocious puberty and pubertal development. Additionally, all review processes underwent peer review, adhering to the PRISMA guidelines. However, due to the heterogeneity among the studies, it was not feasible to conduct a meta-analysis to evaluate the combined effect of air pollution on the risk of precocious puberty. Future research on this topic is necessary, and as more studies become available, we aim to gather sufficient evidence to conduct a meta-analysis.

Conclusion

The evidence suggests that exposure to air pollution may lead to an earlier onset of puberty, although the results of studies have been inconsistent. To address this, further longitudinal studies are needed that accurately assess individual exposure to multiple air pollutants over extended periods. It is crucial to promote policies aimed at reducing exposure to air pollution. Additionally, sharing international data and conducting collaborative studies could provide valuable insights for developing preventive policies concerning exposure to air pollutants.

Authors' contributions

Project administration: Kim HS, Ha E

Conceptualization: Lee R, Oh J, Mun E, Choi JE, Kim KH, Lee JH, Kim HS, Ha E

Methodology & data curation: Kim HS, Ha E

Funding acquisition: Kim HS, Ha E

Writing – original draft: Lee R

Writing – review & editing: Lee R, Oh J, Mun E, Choi JE, Kim KH, Lee JH, Kim HS, Ha E

Conflict of interest

Eunhee Ha has been a dean of the Ewha Womans University College of Medicine since August 2021; however, she was not involved in the peer review process or decision-making. Otherwise, no potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Funding

This study was supported by a project titled “Institute of Ewha-SCL for Environmental Health (IESEH)’’ and Research of Environmental Examination Model for Children and Women (No. 1-2022-0205-001-2).

Data availability

Not applicable.

Acknowledgments

Not applicable.

Supplementary materials

Supplementary materials are available from: https://doi.org/10.12771/emj.2024.e20.

Supplement 1. Keywords used for the systematic review

Supplement 2. Reasons for excluding studies from the systematic review

References

1.

Kim YJ, Kwon A, Jung MK, Kim KE, Suh J, Chae HW, et al. Incidence and prevalence of central precocious puberty in Korea: an epidemiologic study based on a national database. J Pediatr 2019; 208:221-228

2.

Bräuner EV, Busch AS, Eckert-Lind C, Koch T, Hickey M, Juul A. Trends in the incidence of central precocious puberty and normal variant puberty among children in Denmark, 1998 to 2017. JAMA Netw Open 2020; 3(10)e2015665

3.

Eckert-Lind C, Busch AS, Petersen JH, Biro FM, Butler G, Bräuner EV, et al. Worldwide secular trends in age at pubertal onset assessed by breast development among girls: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Pediatr 2020; 174(4)e195881

4.

Sørensen K, Mouritsen A, Aksglaede L, Hagen CP, Mogensen SS, Juul A. Recent secular trends in pubertal timing: implications for evaluation and diagnosis of precocious puberty. Horm Res Paediatr 2012; 77(3):137-145

5.

Parent AS, Teilmann G, Juul A, Skakkebaek NE, Toppari J, Bourguignon JP. The timing of normal puberty and the age limits of sexual precocity: variations around the world, secular trends, and changes after migration. Endocr Rev 2003; 24(5):668-693

6.

Fisher MM, Eugster EA. What is in our environment that effects puberty?. Reprod Toxicol 2014; 44:7-14

7.

Lucaccioni L, Trevisani V, Marrozzini L, Bertoncelli N, Predieri B, Lugli L, et al. Endocrine-disrupting chemicals and their effects during female puberty: a review of current evidence. Int J Mol Sci 2020; 21(6):2078

8.

Wronka I, Kliś K. Effect of air pollution on age at menarche in polish females, born 1993–1998. Sci Rep 2022; 12(1):4820

9.

Jung EM, Kim HS, Park H, Ye S, Lee D, Ha EH. Does exposure to PM10 decrease age at menarche?. Environ Int 2018; 117:16-21

10.

Darbre PD. Overview of air pollution and endocrine disorders. Int J Gen Med 2018; 11:191-207

11.

Anderson JO, Thundiyil JG, Stolbach A. Clearing the air: a review of the effects of particulate matter air pollution on human health. J Med Toxicol 2012; 8(2):166-175

12.

Beelen R, Raaschou-Nielsen O, Stafoggia M, Andersen ZJ, Weinmayr G, Hoffmann B, et al. Effects of long-term exposure to air pollution on natural-cause mortality: an analysis of 22 European cohorts within the multicentre ESCAPE project. Lancet 2014; 383(9919):785-795

13.

Mouritsen A, Aksglaede L, Sørensen K, Sloth Mogensen S, Leffers H, Main KM, et al. Hypothesis: exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals may interfere with timing of puberty. Int J Androl 2010; 33(2):346-359

14.

Yang H, Ge A, Xie H, Li W, Qin Y, Yang W, et al. Effects of ambient air pollution on precocious puberty: a case-crossover analysis in Nanjing, China. J Clin Med 2023; 12(1):282

15.

Zhao T, Triebner K, Markevych I, Standl M, Altug H, de Hoogh K, et al. Outdoor air pollution and hormone-assessed pubertal development in children: results from the GINIplus and LISA birth cohorts. Environ Int 2021; 152:106476

16.

Huang JV, Leung GM, Mary Schooling C. The association of air pollution with pubertal development: evidence from Hong Kong's "Children of 1997" birth cohort. Am J Epidemiol 2017; 185(10):914-923

17.

McGuinn LA, Voss RW, Laurent CA, Greenspan LC, Kushi LH, Windham GC. Residential proximity to traffic and female pubertal development. Environ Int 2016; 94:635-641

18.

Kampa M, Castanas E. Human health effects of air pollution. Environ Pollut 2008; 151(2):362-367

19.

Hombach-Klonisch S, Pocar P, Kietz S, Klonisch T. Molecular actions of polyhalogenated arylhydrocarbons (PAHs) in female reproduction. Curr Med Chem 2005; 12(5):599-616

20.

Rzeczkowska PA, Hou H, Wilson MD, Palmert MR. Epigenetics: a new player in the regulation of mammalian puberty. Neuroendocrinology 2014; 99(3-4):139-155

21.

Chuang KJ, Chan CC, Su TC, Lee CT, Tang CS. The effect of urban air pollution on inflammation, oxidative stress, coagulation, and autonomic dysfunction in young adults. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2007; 176(4):370-376

22.

Oziol L, Alliot F, Botton J, Bimbot M, Huteau V, Levi Y, et al. First characterization of the endocrine-disrupting potential of indoor gaseous and particulate contamination: comparison with urban outdoor air (France). Environ Sci Pollut Res 2017; 24(3):3142-3152

23.

Uldbjerg CS, Koch T, Lim YH, Gregersen LS, Olesen CS, Andersson AM, et al. Prenatal and postnatal exposures to endocrine disrupting chemicals and timing of pubertal onset in girls and boys: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Hum Reprod Update 2022; 28(5):687-716

24.

Wen Y, Liu SD, Lei X, Ling YS, Luo Y, Liu Q. Association of PAEs with precocious puberty in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2015; 12(12):15254-15268

25.

Lee YJ, Jung HW, Kim HY, Choi YJ, Lee YA. Early-life exposure to per- and poly-fluorinated alkyl substances and growth, adiposity, and puberty in children: a systematic review. Front Endocrinol 2021; 12:683297

26.

Bigambo FM, Sun H, Yan W, Wu D, Xia Y, Wang X, et al. Association between phenols exposure and earlier puberty in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Environ Res 2020; 190:110056

27.

Castiello F, Freire C. Exposure to non-persistent pesticides and puberty timing: a systematic review of the epidemiological evidence. Eur J Endocrinol 2021; 184(6):733-749

28.

Golestanzadeh M, Riahi R, Kelishadi R. Association of phthalate exposure with precocious and delayed pubertal timing in girls and boys: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Environ Sci Process Impacts 2020; 22(4):873-894

29.

Vedal S, Kaufman JD. What does multi-pollutant air pollution research mean?. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2011; 183(1):4-6

30.

Roth CL, DiVall S. Consequences of early life programing by genetic and environmental influences: a synthesis regarding pubertal timing. Endocr Dev 2015; 29:134-152